Racing
© Liauzh
George Russell said Carlos Sainz’s proposal to hand out grid penalties to drivers who cause yellow or red flags in qualifying should be studied, but warned that Formula 1 would have to protect fairness without taking away the risk-taking that defines a qualifying lap.
Russell said the idea has been discussed before because a driver who triggers a neutralization can wreck another competitor’s session even if the offender later loses a lap time. “It definitely has been spoken about before that if somebody causes a yellow or a red flag, it should be punished,” Russell said. “It does have an effect on other drivers whether your fastest lap is deleted.”
His caution came from the other side of the argument. Russell said a stricter punishment rule could change the way drivers approach qualifying. “People would also say that drivers are not taking as much risk come qualifying, and you want to see drivers pushing the limits,” he said.
Austria provided the clearest example of the problem Sainz is trying to solve. Russell took pole after Max Verstappen crashed, but the incident also exposed the confusion that can decide a session. Russell said the crash should have been covered by a double yellow, while Kimi Antonelli backed out of his lap because he believed double-waved yellows were being shown. Russell, however, continued under what was in practice a single yellow and kept the lap that secured pole.
That distinction matters because the two signals demand different reactions. Under a double yellow, drivers must slow down and be prepared to stop. Under a single yellow, they only need to reduce speed enough to avoid a penalty.
Russell said the current approach grew out of earlier debates after Baku, when drivers regularly locked up and ran into escape roads. At the time, many felt a double yellow in those situations “completely ruined the lap of another driver,” so the sport settled on what he called a general rule of thumb: “whenever there is an incident in qualifying, it would be a single yellow,” unless the FIA decided the situation required more.
He also pointed to the practical problem of making that call in real time. Russell said the first signal comes from volunteer marshals, not the FIA itself. “It is not the FIA to start with,” he said. “The FIA review it and then upgrades it if they think it is necessary,” but asking for a perfect judgment “in the space of five, six, or 10 seconds” is “just not possible.”
Even so, Russell was clear on the Austria example. “So should the Austria incident have been a double yellow? Of course it should have been,” he said, before adding that past incidents have produced the opposite complaint from drivers who believed a single yellow was enough.
That leaves Sainz’s proposal as more than a simple penalty question. Russell’s view underlines the FIA’s bigger challenge: stopping drivers from unfairly influencing qualifying by causing stoppages, while avoiding a rule set that makes drivers less willing to push at the limit when pole is on the line.